SUPREME COURT RULES IN FAVOUR OF PLP MEMBERSHIP APPLICANTS

The Supreme Court has ruled in favour of the plaintiffs in the ongoing legal dispute surrounding membership applications within the Progressive Labour Party (PLP), finding that the party cannot impose additional restrictions that effectively prevent eligible applicants from being admitted as members.

In its ruling, the Court addressed several key issues, including the validity of the party’s membership verification process, the handling of membership fees, the legality of two addenda introduced by the party, and the rights of individuals whose membership applications were submitted on or before August 31, 2026.

One of the significant findings concerned a bulk payment of $18,775 made on July 28, 2026, from the personal bank account of the Fourth Plaintiff, Winifred Stevens.

The Court found that the payment, which covered 655 general membership applications at $25 each and 24 lifetime membership applications at $100 each, was attributable to the individual applicants.

That means the 679 applicants are entitled to be confirmed as financial members, if they have not already been confirmed, subject to the party carrying out a lawful verification process.

The Court rejected the argument advanced by the defendants’ counsel concerning the attribution of that payment, making clear that membership dues are required from individuals seeking to become financial members, not from applicants simply seeking admission to the party.

The ruling also addressed the Progressive Labour Party’s authority to establish its own administrative procedures for receiving and verifying membership applications.

The Court accepted that the party is entitled to regulate its internal administrative processes, provided those procedures do not conflict with the membership requirements established under Article IV of the PLP Constitution.

However, the Court found that certain provisions contained in the Membership Process and Verification Guide were unlawful to the extent that they imposed requirements inconsistent with the party’s constitutional membership criteria.

In particular, the Court ruled that the Central Committee cannot use the verification process to withhold membership applications submitted by representatives of candidates contesting an upcoming leadership or deputy leadership election.

Two PLP addenda declared unlawful

In another important finding, the Court declared both the First Addendum and Second Addendum unlawful in their existing form.

The Court determined that both addenda required implementation through the formal amendment procedures set out under Article X of the PLP Constitution and Clause 18 of the party’s Bye-Laws.

Those provisions require constitutional or by-law amendments to be approved by a two-thirds majority of delegates at an Annual General Conference or Special Delegates Conference, following the prescribed notice requirements.

The Court also addressed whether the party could introduce amendments retrospectively to affect individuals whose membership applications were submitted by August 31, 2026.

It ruled that any amendments adopted after that date cannot lawfully be used to restrict or remove membership rights already acquired, or rights individuals were entitled to acquire, by August 31.

The judgment further stated that any future amendment attempting to retrospectively apply the restrictions contained in the addenda, or similar provisions, against those applicants would be ultra vires and constitute a breach of their contractual rights, unless each affected individual agreed otherwise.

However, the ruling does not prevent the PLP from adopting the addenda for new applicants whose membership forms are submitted after August 31, 2026.

Court establishes grounds for refusing membership applications

The Court further declared that any PLP membership application duly submitted on or before August 31, 2026, may only be refused or withheld from processing, verification or confirmation on two grounds:

  1. Where the party is unable to confirm that the individual named on the application directly or indirectly submitted the membership form.
  2. Where the party is unable to confirm that the applicant is at least 18 years old.

The Court made clear that the Central Committee may continue to administer and verify membership applications, but it cannot use administrative procedures to introduce additional barriers that effectively change the constitutional requirements for membership.

It also ruled that the party cannot delay the processing of an application or confirmation of membership solely because membership fees have not been paid.

The judgment reiterates the distinction between becoming a member of the party and becoming a financial member, with payment of membership fees being a requirement for members seeking financial membership.

PLP ordered to provide membership list by November 13

As part of the Court’s order, the defendants have been directed to provide the plaintiffs’ attorneys with a complete list of individuals who became members of the Progressive Labour Party between September 1, 2025, and August 31, 2026.

The list must be provided in Excel format, with separate columns identifying each member’s last name, first name and date of birth.

The deadline imposed by the Court is 4:00 p.m. on Friday, November 13, 2026.

Costs awarded to plaintiffs

On the issue of legal costs, the Court granted the plaintiffs their costs in respect of the pre-trial proceedings, subject to specific exceptions relating to portions of the plaintiffs’ September 24 summons application.

The plaintiffs were also awarded their costs in respect of the trial of the Originating Summons, subject to either party filing a Form 31 TC within 14 days to be heard on costs occasioned by the trial.

All costs awarded are on a standard basis and are to be taxed if the parties cannot agree.

The ruling represents a significant development in the legal dispute over the PLP’s membership process, particularly in determining the rights of applicants who submitted membership forms before the August 31 deadline.

While the Court has recognised the party’s authority to manage and verify its membership records, it has also drawn a clear legal boundary: administrative procedures cannot be used to override the party’s Constitution or retrospectively deprive individuals of membership rights.

The November 13 deadline will now be an important next step, as the plaintiffs are set to receive the membership list covering the period identified in the Court’s order.

Any content which is considered unsuitable, unlawful, or offensive, includes personal details, advertises or promotes products, services or websites, or repeats previous comments will be removed.

User comments posted on this website are solely the views and opinions of the comment writer and are not a representation of or reflection of the opinions of TNN or its staff.

TNN reserves the right to remove, edit or censor any comments.

TNN accepts no liability and will not be held accountable for the comments made by users.