HAMILTON, BERMUDA — October 26, 2026 — A constitutional challenge brought by convicted double murderer Le-Veck Roberts is raising serious questions about what police investigators allegedly knew about his role in the killings, whether information potentially contradicting the prosecution’s case was withheld, and the circumstances surrounding an alleged offer to secure his release from prison.
Roberts, who is serving a life sentence for the double murder, has brought constitutional proceedings against the Attorney-General of Bermuda, alleging that police knew he was not the gunman despite his conviction being secured on the basis that he personally carried out the shootings.
The matter came before Mr Justice Southey in the Supreme Court on Friday, October 23, 2026, for a disclosure hearing in Civil Case No. 101 of 2026. The hearing was adjourned pending clarification of the Attorney-General’s position.
Allegations concerning police knowledge
At the centre of Roberts’ constitutional claim is Detective Warren Bundy, whom Roberts alleges testified during his original murder trial despite knowing that Roberts was not the actual shooter.
Roberts relies on a subsequently recorded conversation involving Eron Hill, in which Bundy allegedly made statements approximately 10 years later suggesting that police regarded Roberts as an accessory rather than the gunman who carried out the shootings.
The recording reportedly includes questions raised by Hill concerning Roberts’ visit to Somerset Police Station.
If substantiated, Roberts’ allegations could raise significant questions about the information available to investigators and whether the prosecution’s account of his precise role in the double murder accurately reflected what police knew at the time.
However, the allegations have not been established by a final court ruling.
Alleged offer to secure his freedom
Roberts also alleges that, in 2022, Detective Bundy and former Detective Inspector Michael Redfern arranged for him to be transported from Westgate Correctional Facility to Somerset Police Station.
According to Roberts, the officers offered him an opportunity to provide information about other crimes in exchange for an arrangement that would affect his double-murder conviction and sentence.
He alleges that the proposed deal included securing his release from prison and relocating him to the United Kingdom as a free man. Roberts further claims that the arrangement had already been discussed with or approved by prosecuting authorities.
Roberts maintains that he rejected the proposal because he had not committed the murders and believed he should not have to provide information about unrelated crimes to obtain his freedom.
The officers acknowledge discussing potential sentencing benefits in exchange for cooperation but dispute Roberts’ account of the proposed arrangement.
The precise nature of the discussions, including what was allegedly offered and whether prosecuting authorities approved any proposal, remains a matter requiring clarification and supporting evidence.
Seeking disclosure of records and communications
Through his constitutional proceedings, Roberts is seeking disclosure of police records, communications and other evidence that he says could establish what investigators knew about his alleged role, when they knew it, and whether information potentially undermining the prosecution’s case was withheld from him and his legal representatives.
The disclosure proceedings are significant because the documents and communications sought could help clarify the competing accounts of the investigation and the alleged 2022 discussions.
The Supreme Court hearing on October 23 did not determine the merits of Roberts’ constitutional claim. The matter was adjourned while clarification of the Attorney-General’s position is awaited.
Questions at the heart of the case
The proceedings raise a fundamental question: If police possessed information indicating that Roberts was not the gunman, was that information disclosed during the investigation and trial, and did it have any bearing on his conviction?
The case also places renewed focus on the distinction between being involved in a crime and personally carrying out a shooting, as well as the importance of disclosing potentially relevant evidence in criminal proceedings.
For Roberts, the constitutional action represents an attempt to obtain records and information that he believes could support his allegations and clarify the circumstances surrounding his conviction and continued imprisonment.
The allegations against the officers and the claims concerning the prosecution’s knowledge remain disputed. No final determination has been made by the Supreme Court, and Roberts’ conviction has not been overturned through the proceedings described above.
TNN News will continue to follow the matter as further information becomes available.
Any content which is considered unsuitable, unlawful, or offensive, includes personal details, advertises or promotes products, services or websites, or repeats previous comments will be removed.
User comments posted on this website are solely the views and opinions of the comment writer and are not a representation of or reflection of the opinions of TNN or its staff.
TNN reserves the right to remove, edit or censor any comments.
TNN accepts no liability and will not be held accountable for the comments made by users.