Fallout is emerging from sections of the Bermuda community following the Bermuda Industrial Union’s 80th Anniversary Gala Banquet, where the keynote speaker was international political figure Moses “Shyne” Barrow.
While some attendees were reportedly unaware beforehand that Mr. Moses “Shyne” Barrow would deliver the keynote address, the greater concern being raised by some members of the community is not necessarily his personal story of redemption, but his reported criminal history in the United States dating back approximately 25 years.
Questions are now being raised about how Mr. Barrow, who has reportedly served approximately ten years in prison following a firearms-related conviction stemming from a shooting incident at a New York nightclub, was permitted to enter Bermuda and obtain authorization to work in the country.
TNN News understands that Mr. Barrow has previously spoken publicly about his incarceration and maintained that he was wrongfully convicted. However, individuals familiar with the circumstances have challenged that account, pointing to evidence and testimony that led to his conviction.
Moses “Shyne” Barrow born Jamal Michael Barrow, served time in Clinton Correctional Facility in Dannemora, New York, where he was incarcerated for his role in a nightclub shooting incident in 1999. He was sentenced to ten years in prison and began serving his sentence in early 2001. After his release in 2009, he was deported to Belize and later moved to Jerusalem, where he started Judaism.
Mr. Barrow has since gone on to pursue a career in politics and served as a Member of Parliament in Belize.
At the BIU banquet, his appearance has prompted a broader question:
Would a Bermudian with a comparable firearms conviction receive the same level of consideration when attempting to travel, work, or obtain immigration permission in another jurisdiction with support from the Bermuda Government?
And, given Bermuda’s own history of gun violence, some are questioning whether the government’s immigration and work-permit policies should be applied differently when an individual has a serious conviction involving a firearm.
One person who attended Friday night’s event spoke with TNN News about their reaction to the evening and the political tone of the banquet.
The individual described the event as heavily focused on the current political divisions within the Progressive Labour Party, despite being billed as a celebration of the Bermuda Industrial Union’s 80th anniversary.
The attendee pointed to several political figures who addressed the gathering, including Premier David Burt, MP Curtis Dickinson, Minister Jason Hayward and other political representatives.
The individual also referenced the musical performance of a former Bermuda Idol contestant, who performed “Bridge Over Troubled Water,” saying the themes of unity and division appeared particularly significant given the current political tensions within the PLP.
Asked whether the evening came across as a political event, the attendee responded that, in their view, it was.
“I would say it was clear that it was a PLP event that happened to be celebrating the union.”
But it was the keynote speaker that prompted another line of questioning.
TNN subsequently sought clarification from the Minister of Labour and Immigration, the Honourable Jason Hayward, regarding Mr. Shineborough’s entry into Bermuda and his authorization to work.
The Minister has now confirmed to TNN News that he granted Mr. Moses “Shyne” Barrow a work permit.
That confirmation raises further questions about the process that was followed before the permit was approved.
What information was available to the Minister and the Department of Immigration regarding Mr. Barrow’s criminal history?
Was the firearms conviction considered as part of the assessment?
Were any additional checks or consultations conducted before the permit was granted?
And does Bermuda’s immigration framework provide discretion for individuals with serious criminal convictions to enter the jurisdiction for employment or speaking engagements?
There is also a wider issue of fairness.
Bermudians with criminal convictions can face significant restrictions when attempting to enter other countries, particularly where firearms or other serious offences are involved.
The question being asked by some members of the public is whether Bermuda’s standards are equally stringent when determining who is permitted to enter Bermuda and work here.
That question carries particular weight given Bermuda’s ongoing concerns surrounding gun violence and illegal firearms.
TNN News is seeking further clarification from the Minister and the Department of Immigration on the specific circumstances surrounding the approval, including the criteria considered and whether any special exemption or discretionary authority was involved.
The issue is not whether a person who has served their sentence should forever be denied an opportunity to rebuild their life.
Rather, the public-interest question is whether the same standards applied to foreign nationals seeking permission to work in Bermuda are consistently applied—and whether the public is entitled to understand how such decisions are made.
Another professional business owner at the banquet stated “There is nothing positive in his bio that stands out other than his pilgrimage into Judaism.
His history precedes him as being involved in gang activity. While it’s convenient to now say that he was the fall guy and shift blame to diddy, he continued to pursue the music lifestyle well after incarceration (unsuccessfully) so it appears that politics is his plan c relying strictly on his popularity to push him forward.
Fast forward to Bermuda and the rise in gun violence, it’s in poor taste that the minister would accept this gentleman as a model citizen to speak at any event here in Bermuda on behalf of the leading party.
What message can he truly give to our community other than a global apology with no follow through. I don’t see any real content that would give our community anything to glean other than to say there’s life after prison and that’s simply not enough to warrant a full expense paid political showcase to our island.”
TNN News will publish the Minister’s full statement below and will continue to seek answers to the questions surrounding Mr. Barrow’s entry into Bermuda and the granting of his work permit.
“Thank you for the queries raised regarding the decision to grant entry and a short-term work permit to the Honourable Moses “Shyne” Barrow.”
“While immigration policies rightfully scrutinise historic convictions, the system also affords the necessary discretion to recognise extraordinary, documented rehabilitation and public service.
“It is also important to note Mr Barrow’s entry into Bermuda was classified as a visitor, not an application for residency such as a standard permit, which carries a higher threshold of scrutiny.
“As the Minister, I believe it is important not to reduce Mr. Barrow to a single chapter of his past and to recognise the reality of his profound transformation.
“Over the past decade, he has built a distinguished career in public service, formally serving as the Leader of the Opposition in Belize. In this capacity, he has championed critical social policies, economic development, and international diplomacy.
“His presence in Bermuda serves a clear and positive public interest. Invited by the Bermuda Industrial Union as the keynote speaker for their 80th-anniversary Labour Day Banquet, fittingly themed “The Courage to Change”, Mr. Barrow stands as a global example of restorative justice. His visit has already fostered productive dialogue with local leadership, highlighting a shared commitment to progressive governance and community empowerment.
“Decades spent evaluating outcomes within the criminal justice system consistently reveal that society benefits most when genuine rehabilitation is acknowledged and celebrated. The decision to welcome Mr. Barrow to Bermuda is not an oversight of his past, but a pragmatic recognition of the leader he is today. It honours the reality of his transformation and provides the community with an invaluable perspective on the power of redemption.”
Any content which is considered unsuitable, unlawful, or offensive, includes personal details, advertises or promotes products, services or websites, or repeats previous comments will be removed.
User comments posted on this website are solely the views and opinions of the comment writer and are not a representation of or reflection of the opinions of TNN or its staff.
TNN reserves the right to remove, edit or censor any comments.
TNN accepts no liability and will not be held accountable for the comments made by users.